Watchmen
 |
Cast: Jackie Earle Haley, Malin Akerman, Billy Crudup, Patrick Wilson, Carla Gugino, Matthew Goode,
Jeffrey Dean Morgan.
Directed by Zack Snyder.
Story: Superhero smorgasbord.
Running Time: 2hrs 42 minutes.
UK certificate 18, US certificate R. |
It's the first must-see movie of 2009 and, surely, it can't fail to be brilliant,
can it? Bugger. It can and it has.
Watchmen is the latest in a long line of comic book adaptations and it was supposed
to be the best of the lot. The dark, morally ambiguous plot should have given it
the perfect timing to slot in nonchalantly behind
The Dark Knight and set new standards for the genre.
And, to be fair, if you're a fan of the comic book then you'll probably jizz in
your pants in sheer excitement. For the regular cinema-goer who's never picked up
a comic book, however, it's a confusing mess of squished-up plot and under-developed
characters that stands no chance of striking any emotional chord, even though it
has nearly three hours in which to try. Several times I found myself recapping in
my head, thinking, "OK, so she's whats-her-face's daughter, those two
used to do the reproductive rhumba ... so who's that guy again?" - and to make
matters worse, there's so much fart-arsing around with the time-line that it's
never quite clear which bits are in the here-and-now. Watching a movie shouldn't
be this hard.
It's not all bad, though. The effects are very nice throughout, even down to
Billy Crudup's CGI schlong that we see rather too much of, dangling around in the
wind. Despite being confusing, the huge running time actually passes pretty quickly
and one or two of the characters (Rorschach, Dr Manhattan) are genuinely interesting
and the ending is almost intelligent - as long as you don't think about it too
much - but beyond that it's hard to find much to compliment.
Director Zack Snyder's last movie was 300, so we could reasonably expect
a vivid visual style - but it never shows up.
None of the performances are noteworthy and as such it's almost impossible to
identify with any of the characters - by the end I really didn't give a toss who
lived and who died. But the biggest criticism of all is that it takes itself WAY
too seriously. Comic books are supposed to be a bit of fun - if you're going to
play them straight then you have to immerse them in their shadowy world, like the
last two Batman movies - but even they have their lighter comedy moments.
Watchmen's smiles trade on one solitary line - "I'm not a comic book villain" - but
this arrives at the wrong moment to be effective and seems almost apologetic.
Have some fun with it, for heaven's sake.
Watchmen is a shadow of the movie it should have been. Whilst trying so very hard,
and probably succeeding, to please the comic book fans, it alienates the majority.
Perhaps the crystallising moment appears early on, when Carla Gugino moans about
being a 67 year old woman. "No you're not," I thought, "you're clearly a 30 year
old in bad make-up." It never improved from there.
Who watches the Watchmen? Lots of confused and disappointed viewers, that's who.
I enjoyed this film: 3/5
I think the average moviegoer will enjoy it: 3/5 (but
5/5 if you read the comics).
Testosterone Satisfaction Rating: 3/5 - Malin Akerman gets naked but it's a
dark scene. Billy Crudup's CGI sausage is continuously flapping around. Some overblown violence, a la
Sin City but less stylised. Not really for kids.
To enjoy this film: be a fan of the comic books.
Watchmen was released in the UK on 6th March 2009.
|